Other Ways to Say “Thank You for Your Advice”: A Comprehensive Guide

Expressing gratitude for advice is a crucial social skill. While “Thank you for your advice” is perfectly acceptable, mastering alternative expressions can enrich your communication and demonstrate a deeper level of appreciation.

This article explores various ways to convey your thanks for helpful guidance, enhancing your English proficiency and communication skills. This article is designed for English language learners, students, professionals, and anyone looking to refine their expressive abilities.

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Definition: Expressing Gratitude for Advice
  3. Structural Breakdown of Gratitude Phrases
  4. Types and Categories of Gratitude Expressions
  5. Examples of Gratitude Expressions
  6. Usage Rules for Expressing Gratitude
  7. Common Mistakes When Expressing Gratitude
  8. Practice Exercises
  9. Advanced Topics in Expressing Gratitude
  10. Frequently Asked Questions
  11. Conclusion

Definition: Expressing Gratitude for Advice

Expressing gratitude for advice involves more than just uttering “thank you.” It’s about acknowledging the value of the guidance received and conveying genuine appreciation. These expressions range from formal acknowledgments suitable for professional settings to informal phrases perfect for casual conversations.

The key is to choose words that accurately reflect your feelings and the impact of the advice.

This form of expression falls under the broader category of speech acts, specifically expressives. Expressives convey the speaker’s psychological state about a certain situation. In this case, the psychological state is gratitude, and the situation is the receipt of helpful advice. Effective expressions of gratitude also strengthen interpersonal relationships and foster positive communication.

Structural Breakdown of Gratitude Phrases

Gratitude phrases typically consist of several key components that contribute to their overall meaning and impact. Understanding these components allows you to construct your own personalized and effective expressions of thanks.

Here’s a breakdown of the common structural elements:

  • Acknowledgment of the Advice: Directly referencing the advice received demonstrates that you were paying attention and valued the input. This can be done using phrases like “Your advice on…” or “Regarding your suggestion about…”
  • Expression of Gratitude: This is the core of the phrase, using words or phrases that convey thanks, such as “thank you,” “I appreciate,” or “I’m grateful.”
  • Explanation of Impact: Describing how the advice helped you provides context and emphasizes its value. Phrases like “It really helped me…” or “It made a big difference…” are effective here.
  • Statement of Future Action (Optional): Indicating how you plan to use the advice or what you have already done with it reinforces your appreciation and shows that you took the advice seriously.
  • Closing Remark: A polite closing, such as “Thanks again” or “I really appreciate it,” adds a final touch of sincerity.

Types and Categories of Gratitude Expressions

There are various ways to express gratitude for advice, each suited to different contexts and relationships. Understanding these categories will help you choose the most appropriate expression.

Formal Expressions

These are suitable for professional settings, interactions with superiors, or situations where a high degree of respect is required. They often use more sophisticated vocabulary and a more structured sentence format.

Informal Expressions

These are appropriate for casual conversations with friends, family, or close colleagues. They tend to be more relaxed and use simpler language.

Expressions Emphasizing Helpfulness

These expressions highlight the practical value of the advice and how it assisted you in a specific situation. They focus on the positive outcome resulting from the guidance.

Expressions Emphasizing Impact

These phrases focus on the broader impact of the advice, emphasizing how it influenced your thinking, decision-making, or overall approach to a problem. They convey a deeper level of appreciation.

Expressions Offering Reciprocity

These expressions not only convey thanks but also offer to return the favor in the future. They strengthen the relationship and demonstrate a willingness to support the other person.

Examples of Gratitude Expressions

To illustrate the different types of gratitude expressions, here are several examples categorized by their level of formality and emphasis.

Formal Examples

The following table provides examples of formal expressions of gratitude for advice. These are suitable for professional settings and interactions with superiors.

Expression Context
“I am deeply grateful for your insightful guidance on this matter.” Addressing a mentor after receiving career advice.
“Your advice was invaluable in navigating this complex situation. Thank you.” Emailing a supervisor after successfully resolving a problem.
“I sincerely appreciate your expertise and the time you took to advise me.” Speaking to a consultant after a helpful consultation.
“Thank you for your counsel; it has proven to be extremely beneficial to our project.” Addressing a board member during a project update.
“I extend my sincere gratitude for your advice, which has significantly improved our strategy.” Presenting to senior management after implementing their suggestions.
“Your input was instrumental in achieving this positive outcome. Thank you for your guidance.” Acknowledging a colleague’s contribution in a team meeting.
“I want to formally express my gratitude for your advice; it was crucial to my decision-making process.” Writing a thank-you note to a senior advisor.
“Your recommendation was particularly helpful. I appreciate your willingness to share your knowledge.” Speaking with a subject matter expert after a training session.
“I am most appreciative of the advice you provided. It helped clarify several key issues.” Responding to a mentor’s email offering guidance.
“Thank you for offering your perspective; it has been incredibly valuable to our team.” Addressing a guest speaker after a presentation.
“I am indebted to you for your advice. It was precisely what I needed to hear.” Speaking to a trusted professional advisor.
“Your recommendation was particularly helpful. I appreciate your willingness to share your knowledge.” Speaking with a subject matter expert after a training session.
“I am most appreciative of the advice you provided. It helped clarify several key issues.” Responding to a mentor’s email offering guidance.
“Thank you for offering your perspective; it has been incredibly valuable to our team.” Addressing a guest speaker after a presentation.
“I am indebted to you for your advice. It was precisely what I needed to hear.” Speaking to a trusted professional advisor.
“Your advice has been invaluable to the success of this project. I am most grateful.” Formally acknowledging a key contributor’s role.
“I wish to express my sincere thanks for your guidance. It has made a significant impact.” Writing a letter of appreciation to a mentor.
“Your expertise has been invaluable, and I am truly grateful for your advice.” Speaking to a consultant after a successful project.
“I am extremely appreciative of your advice and support during this challenging period.” Speaking to a senior colleague after overcoming a professional hurdle.
“Your insights were particularly helpful, and I am deeply grateful for your time and expertise.” Acknowledging a mentor’s support after a successful presentation.

Informal Examples

The following table provides examples of informal expressions of gratitude for advice. These are appropriate for conversations with friends, family, or close colleagues.

Expression Context
“Thanks a bunch for the advice! It really helped.” Texting a friend after following their suggestion.
“I really appreciate your input; it made a huge difference.” Talking to a close colleague after solving a problem.
“Your advice was spot on! Thanks so much.” Chatting with a friend after their advice proved correct.
“I really appreciate your input; it made a huge difference.” Talking to a close colleague after solving a problem.
“Your advice was spot on! Thanks so much.” Chatting with a friend after their advice proved correct.
“That was great advice, thanks! I don’t know what I would have done without it.” Speaking to a family member after receiving helpful guidance.
“Thanks for the tip! It worked like a charm.” Messaging a friend after their suggestion solved a problem.
“I owe you one for that advice! Really appreciate it.” Talking to a friend after their advice helped avoid a mistake.
“Thanks so much, that advice was super helpful!” Speaking casually with a friend after receiving useful feedback.
“You’re a lifesaver! Thanks for the advice.” Expressing gratitude to a friend who helped in a crisis.
“Thanks for the heads up! I really appreciate it.” Responding to a friend who gave a helpful warning.
“I appreciate you looking out for me; your advice was awesome!” Speaking to a friend who offered proactive guidance.
“Cheers for the advice! It was just what I needed.” Thanking a friend in a casual setting.
“Thanks a million! Your advice was a game-changer.” Expressing high gratitude to a friend.
“That was brilliant advice, thanks! You always know what to say.” Complimenting a friend’s insightful advice.
“Thanks for the heads up! I really appreciate it.” Responding to a friend who gave a helpful warning.
“I appreciate you looking out for me; your advice was awesome!” Speaking to a friend who offered proactive guidance.
“Cheers for the advice! It was just what I needed.” Thanking a friend in a casual setting.
“Thanks a million! Your advice was a game-changer.” Expressing high gratitude to a friend.
“That was brilliant advice, thanks! You always know what to say.” Complimenting a friend’s insightful advice.
“Seriously, thank you so much for the advice. It was perfect.” Expressing genuine gratitude to a friend.
“I can’t thank you enough for your advice. You’re the best!” Speaking to a close friend who has always been supportive.
“Dude, thanks for the advice! It totally worked.” A casual thank you to a male friend.
See also  Synonyms for "Fancy": A Comprehensive Guide

Helpfulness Examples

The following table provides examples of expressions that emphasize the helpfulness of the advice received.

Expression Context
“Your advice was incredibly helpful; it got me through a tough spot.” Speaking to a mentor after overcoming a challenge.
“I found your advice extremely helpful in resolving the issue.” Emailing a colleague after using their advice successfully.
“Your suggestions were very helpful, and I was able to implement them immediately.” Responding to a manager after receiving feedback.
“Your suggestions were very helpful, and I was able to implement them immediately.” Responding to a manager after receiving feedback.
“The advice you gave me was super helpful; it saved me a lot of time.” Speaking to a friend after their advice improved efficiency.
“I really appreciated how helpful your advice was; it simplified everything.” Expressing gratitude to a colleague for simplifying a complex task.
“Your advice proved to be extremely helpful, and I’m grateful for your assistance.” Writing a thank-you note to a consultant.
“I can’t thank you enough for your helpful advice; it made a significant difference.” Speaking to a mentor after achieving a goal.
“Your advice was instrumental in helping me overcome this obstacle.” Acknowledging the impact of advice on overcoming a challenge.
“I found your insights incredibly helpful; they provided clarity and direction.” Expressing gratitude for advice that provided guidance.
“The advice you gave was exceptionally helpful; it allowed me to avoid a major pitfall.” Thanking someone for advice that prevented a problem.
“I am very grateful for your helpful advice; it perfectly addressed my needs.” Expressing appreciation for advice that was perfectly tailored.
“Your advice was not only helpful but also very insightful; thank you for sharing.” Acknowledging the depth and usefulness of the advice.
“I truly appreciate how helpful your advice has been; it’s made a world of difference.” Speaking to a mentor about the significant positive impact of their advice.
“Your advice was remarkably helpful; it provided exactly the solution I needed.” Expressing profound thanks for advice that offered a precise solution.
“The advice you gave was exceptionally helpful; it allowed me to avoid a major pitfall.” Thanking someone for advice that prevented a problem.
“I am very grateful for your helpful advice; it perfectly addressed my needs.” Expressing appreciation for advice that was perfectly tailored.
“Your advice was not only helpful but also very insightful; thank you for sharing.” Acknowledging the depth and usefulness of the advice.
“I truly appreciate how helpful your advice has been; it’s made a world of difference.” Speaking to a mentor about the significant positive impact of their advice.
“Your advice was remarkably helpful; it provided exactly the solution I needed.” Expressing profound thanks for advice that offered a precise solution.
“Your advice was remarkably helpful; it provided exactly the solution I needed.” Expressing profound thanks for advice that offered a precise solution.
“Your advice was so helpful, I don’t know what I would have done without it!” Speaking to a friend after successfully following their advice.
“The advice you gave me was exceptionally helpful and very much appreciated.” Expressing sincere gratitude for highly effective advice.

Impact Examples

The following table provides examples of expressions that emphasize the impact of the advice on your decisions or outcomes.

Expression Context
“Your advice had a significant impact on my decision-making process.” Speaking to a mentor after making an important decision.
“I’m grateful for the impact your advice had on the outcome of this project.” Emailing a supervisor after a successful project completion.
“Your insight significantly influenced my approach to the problem, thank you.” Responding to a colleague after resolving a challenging issue.
“I’m grateful for the impact your advice had on the outcome of this project.” Emailing a supervisor after a successful project completion.
“Your insight significantly influenced my approach to the problem, thank you.” Responding to a colleague after resolving a challenging issue.
“The impact of your advice has been profound; I’m truly grateful.” Expressing deep appreciation to a trusted advisor.
“Your advice has greatly influenced my perspective; thank you for sharing it.” Speaking to a mentor after a shift in mindset.
“The advice you provided had a transformative impact; I’m deeply appreciative.” Expressing gratitude for advice that led to significant personal growth.
“Your advice has positively impacted my career trajectory, thank you.” Acknowledging the influence of advice on professional growth.
“I’m truly grateful for the lasting impact your advice has had on my life.” Expressing appreciation for advice with long-term positive effects.
“Your advice not only helped me but also had a ripple effect, benefiting the entire team.” Acknowledging the widespread impact of helpful advice.
“I am so grateful for the impact of your advice; it changed everything for the better.” Expressing profound thanks for advice that brought about positive change.
“Your advice has been a catalyst for significant improvements in my work.” Acknowledging advice as a key factor in professional improvement.
“The impact of your wisdom is undeniable; thank you for guiding me.” Expressing gratitude for wise counsel and its lasting effects.
“I’m immensely grateful for the impact your advice has had; it’s been invaluable.” Expressing deep appreciation for advice that has been exceptionally valuable.
“Your advice not only helped me but also had a ripple effect, benefiting the entire team.” Acknowledging the widespread impact of helpful advice.
“I am so grateful for the impact of your advice; it changed everything for the better.” Expressing profound thanks for advice that brought about positive change.
“Your advice has been a catalyst for significant improvements in my work.” Acknowledging advice as a key factor in professional improvement.
“The impact of your wisdom is undeniable; thank you for guiding me.” Expressing gratitude for wise counsel and its lasting effects.
“I’m immensely grateful for the impact your advice has had; it’s been invaluable.” Expressing deep appreciation for advice that has been exceptionally valuable.
“The advice you gave me had a profound impact on my life, thank you so much!” Thanking someone for life-changing advice.
“I am forever grateful for the positive impact your advice had on my career.” Expressing lasting gratitude for career-changing advice.
“The advice you gave me was life-changing, thank you. I will never forget it.” Expressing deep gratitude for advice that has had a significant, permanent impact.
See also  Best Word Substitution Techniques for Writers

Reciprocity Examples

The following table provides examples of expressions that offer reciprocity in addition to expressing gratitude.

Expression Context
“Thank you for your advice; let me know if there’s anything I can do to help you in return.” Speaking to a colleague after receiving assistance.
“I really appreciate your guidance; please don’t hesitate to ask if you need anything from me.” Emailing a mentor after receiving valuable advice.
“Thanks for the advice; I’m happy to return the favor anytime.” Speaking to a friend after receiving helpful suggestions.
“I really appreciate your guidance; please don’t hesitate to ask if you need anything from me.” Emailing a mentor after receiving valuable advice.
“Thanks for the advice; I’m happy to return the favor anytime.” Speaking to a friend after receiving helpful suggestions.
“I owe you one for that advice; feel free to call on me if you ever need anything.” Expressing gratitude to a colleague while offering reciprocal support.
“Thanks so much for the tip; let me know if you ever need a hand with anything.” Offering assistance to a friend in return for their advice.
“I appreciate your help; I’m always here to lend an ear or offer advice if you need it.” Expressing gratitude while offering ongoing support.
“Thank you for sharing your expertise; I’d be glad to reciprocate in any way I can.” Offering to share your skills in return for expert advice.
“Your advice was invaluable; please let me know how I can be of assistance to you.” Expressing gratitude and offering to help in any capacity.
“I’m grateful for your advice; don’t hesitate to reach out if you ever need my help.” Offering support to someone who has been helpful.
“Thank you for your guidance; I’m available to offer my expertise should you need it.” Offering specific skills or knowledge in return for advice.
“I appreciate your advice so much; please feel free to ask for my assistance anytime.” Offering open-ended support in exchange for advice.
“Thanks a million for the advice; I’m happy to return the favor whenever you need it.” Expressing high gratitude and offering reciprocal help.
“Your advice was a lifesaver; please don’t hesitate to ask if you need anything at all.” Offering comprehensive support in return for life-changing advice.
“I’m grateful for your advice; don’t hesitate to reach out if you ever need my help.” Offering support to someone who has been helpful.
“Thank you for your guidance; I’m available to offer my expertise should you need it.” Offering specific skills or knowledge in return for advice.
“I appreciate your advice so much; please feel free to ask for my assistance anytime.” Offering open-ended support in exchange for advice.
“Thanks a million for the advice; I’m happy to return the favor whenever you need it.” Expressing high gratitude and offering reciprocal help.
“Your advice was a lifesaver; please don’t hesitate to ask if you need anything at all.” Offering comprehensive support in return for life-changing advice.
“Thanks for the advice, I owe you one. Anything I can do for you, just ask!” Offering a blank check of support to someone who’s provided great advice.
“I’m so grateful for your advice. I’m here for you if you ever need anything at all.” Offering unconditional support to someone who has provided invaluable assistance.
“Thanks for your advice. I’d be happy to help you with your project if you need an extra pair of hands.” Offering specific help in return for advice.

Usage Rules for Expressing Gratitude

Expressing gratitude effectively requires adhering to certain usage rules to ensure clarity, sincerity, and appropriateness.

  • Be Specific: Vague expressions of gratitude can seem insincere. Referencing the specific advice you received shows that you were paying attention and valued the input.
  • Match Formality to Context: Choose formal expressions for professional settings and informal expressions for casual conversations.
  • Be Sincere: Genuine gratitude is more impactful. Express your thanks in a way that reflects your true feelings.
  • Use Proper Grammar: Ensure that your expressions are grammatically correct to avoid miscommunication.
  • Consider Cultural Norms: Different cultures have different customs regarding expressing gratitude. Be mindful of these norms when interacting with people from different backgrounds.

Common Mistakes When Expressing Gratitude

Even native English speakers sometimes make mistakes when expressing gratitude. Being aware of these common errors can help you avoid them.

Incorrect Correct Explanation
“Thanks for the advise.” “Thanks for the advice.” “Advice” is an uncountable noun and does not have a plural form.
“I appreciate to help me.” “I appreciate you helping me.” or “I appreciate your help.” The correct grammatical structure is “appreciate + gerund” or “appreciate + noun.”
“Thank you for your advices.” “Thank you for your advice.” Again, “advice” is an uncountable noun.
“I am thankful for your help, but…” “I am thankful for your help.” (followed by a separate statement if needed) Avoid immediately negating your gratitude with a “but.”
“Thanks, I guess.” “Thanks, I appreciate it.” “I guess” undermines the sincerity of your gratitude.
“Thanks for the advise.” “Thanks for the advice.” “Advice” is an uncountable noun and does not have a plural form.
“I appreciate to help me.” “I appreciate you helping me.” or “I appreciate your help.” The correct grammatical structure is “appreciate + gerund” or “appreciate + noun.”
“Thank you for your advices.” “Thank you for your advice.” Again, “advice” is an uncountable noun.
“I am thankful for your help, but…” “I am thankful for your help.” (followed by a separate statement if needed) Avoid immediately negating your gratitude with a “but.”
“Thanks, I guess.” “Thanks, I appreciate it.” “I guess” undermines the sincerity of your gratitude.
“Thanks for advice.” “Thanks for the advice.” Adding the definite article “the” is generally more appropriate when referring to specific advice.
“Thank you for help me.” “Thank you for helping me.” Use the gerund form “helping” after “for” in this context.
See also  Antonyms for Sympathy: Understanding Opposite Emotions

Practice Exercises

Test your understanding of expressing gratitude with these practice exercises. Choose the most appropriate expression for each scenario.

Exercise 1: Formal Expressions

Question Answer
You received career advice from your mentor. Which expression is most appropriate? “I am deeply grateful for your insightful guidance on this matter.”
Your supervisor’s advice helped you resolve a complex problem. How do you express your gratitude in an email? “Your advice was invaluable in navigating this complex situation. Thank you.”
A consultant provided helpful advice during a consultation. What do you say to them? “I sincerely appreciate your expertise and the time you took to advise me.”
A board member’s advice proved beneficial to your project. How do you acknowledge their contribution during a project update? “Thank you for your counsel; it has proven to be extremely beneficial to our project.”
You implemented senior management’s suggestions, which significantly improved your strategy. How do you express your gratitude during a presentation? “I extend my sincere gratitude for your advice, which has significantly improved our strategy.”
A colleague’s input was instrumental in achieving a positive outcome. How do you acknowledge their contribution in a team meeting? “Your input was instrumental in achieving this positive outcome. Thank you for your guidance.”
You are writing a thank-you note to a senior advisor. Which expression is most fitting? “I want to formally express my gratitude for your advice; it was crucial to my decision-making process.”
A subject matter expert shared helpful knowledge during a training session. How do you thank them? “Your recommendation was particularly helpful. I appreciate your willingness to share your knowledge.”
Your mentor sent you an email offering guidance. How do you respond to show your appreciation? “I am most appreciative of the advice you provided. It helped clarify several key issues.”
A guest speaker provided valuable perspective during a presentation. How do you address them to express your thanks? “Thank you for offering your perspective; it has been incredibly valuable to our team.”

Exercise 2: Informal Expressions

Question Answer
A friend’s suggestion helped you. What do you text them? “Thanks a bunch for the advice! It really helped.”
A close colleague’s input made a huge difference in solving a problem. How do you thank them? “I really appreciate your input; it made a huge difference.”
A friend’s advice was spot on. What do you say in a casual chat? “Your advice was spot on! Thanks so much.”
A family member gave you helpful guidance. How do you express your thanks? “That was great advice, thanks! I don’t know what I would have done without it.”
A friend’s suggestion solved a problem. What do you message them? “Thanks for the tip! It worked like a charm.”
A friend’s advice helped you avoid a mistake. How do you express your gratitude? “I owe you one for that advice! Really appreciate it.”
A friend gave you useful feedback. How do you thank them casually? “Thanks so much, that advice was super helpful!”
A friend helped you in a crisis. How do you express your gratitude? “You’re a lifesaver! Thanks for the advice.”
A friend gave you a helpful warning. How do you respond? “Thanks for the heads up! I really appreciate it.”
A friend offered proactive guidance. How do you thank them? “I appreciate you looking out for me; your advice was awesome!”

Exercise 3: Choosing the Right Expression

Scenario Appropriate Expression
You are writing an email to your professor after they helped you with your research paper. “I am

deeply grateful for your insightful guidance on my research paper. Your advice was invaluable.”

You’re talking to a close friend who gave you great advice on a personal matter. “Thanks a million for the advice! It was a game-changer.”
Your manager gave you advice that helped you land a new client. You want to express your gratitude formally. “Your guidance was instrumental in securing this new client. I sincerely appreciate your support.”
A colleague’s suggestion saved you a lot of time on a project. You want to thank them informally. “Thanks for the tip! It saved me a ton of time.”
You want to thank your mentor for their long-term guidance and support. “I am truly grateful for the lasting impact your advice has had on my career.”

Advanced Topics in Expressing Gratitude

Beyond the basic expressions, there are more nuanced ways to convey gratitude. These advanced techniques involve deeper emotional intelligence and a greater understanding of interpersonal dynamics.

  • Personalized Expressions: Tailor your expressions to the individual and the specific situation. Show that you understand their perspective and appreciate their unique contribution.
  • Combining Verbal and Nonverbal Communication: Use body language, such as eye contact and a warm smile, to reinforce your verbal expressions of gratitude.
  • Expressing Gratitude Publicly: Acknowledge someone’s contribution in a public setting, such as a team meeting or social media post, to amplify your appreciation.
  • Following Up: After expressing initial gratitude, follow up with updates on how you implemented the advice and the positive results you achieved.
  • Demonstrating Gratitude Through Actions: Go beyond words and show your appreciation through your actions, such as offering assistance, providing support, or advocating for the other person.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it necessary to always express gratitude for advice?

Yes, expressing gratitude is a fundamental social norm and demonstrates respect and appreciation for the other person’s input. However, the level of formality and the specific expression should be tailored to the context and relationship.

What if the advice didn’t work out as expected?

Even if the advice didn’t lead to the desired outcome, it’s still important to acknowledge the effort and intention behind it. You can say something like, “I appreciate you taking the time to offer your advice.

While it didn’t work out in this instance, I still value your input.”

How can I make my expressions of gratitude more sincere?

Focus on the specific value of the advice and how it helped you. Be genuine in your tone and body language.

Avoid generic or insincere phrases. Show that you were truly listening and that you appreciate the other person’s effort.

What if I’m not a naturally expressive person?

Start with simple, sincere expressions and gradually expand your repertoire. Practice using different phrases in various contexts.

Focus on conveying your genuine appreciation, even if it feels a bit awkward at first.

Is it ever inappropriate to express gratitude?

In rare cases, expressing gratitude might be inappropriate if the advice was clearly malicious or self-serving. However, in most situations, it’s better to err on the side of expressing gratitude, even if it’s just a simple “thank you.”

Conclusion

Mastering the art of expressing gratitude for advice is a valuable skill that can enhance your communication, strengthen your relationships, and foster a positive environment. By understanding the different types of expressions, adhering to usage rules, and avoiding common mistakes, you can effectively convey your appreciation and make a lasting impression.

So, go forth and express your gratitude with confidence and sincerity!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *